河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2025, Vol. 50 ›› Issue (3): 149-160.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-6378.2025.03.012

• 青年论坛 • 上一篇    

论董仲舒不以五行推阴阳、言灾异

王泽春   

  1. 西南政法大学 哲学系, 重庆 401120
  • 收稿日期:2023-08-07 发布日期:2025-05-19
  • 作者简介:王泽春(1988—),男,山西祁县人,博士,西南政法大学哲学系讲师,主要研究方向:先秦哲学、两汉哲学、儒学史。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大项目“近代哲学家对中国学术思想的脉络梳理与当代启示”(21&BZD053);西南政法大学2019年校级科研资助项目(2019XZQN-13)

On Dong Zhongshu without Using the Five Elements to Infer Yin and Yang and Explain Disasters and Anomalies

WANG Zechun   

  1. Department of Philosophy, Southwest University of Political Science and Law, Chongqing 401120, China
  • Received:2023-08-07 Published:2025-05-19

摘要: 很多学者认为董仲舒既有阴阳思想,也有五行思想,并且认为董仲舒以五行推阴阳、解释灾异。《汉书·五行志》中的董仲舒“始推阴阳”的完整表述是“推阴阳言灾异”,就是用阴阳理论解释灾异的产生,而不是以五行推阴阳。根据可靠的董仲舒文献,在董仲舒的思想中,阴阳是他论述刑徳、君臣、四时、灾异的理论基础;而“五行”二字则是受流行观念的影响偶然提到一次,不能因此就认为他有五行思想。当然,董仲舒更没有把阴阳与五行结合起来。虽然,董仲舒的灾异著述主要收录在《汉书·五行志》,但是,董仲舒解释灾异的理论并不是五行,而是“原天意”和“推阴阳”。

关键词: 董仲舒, 阴阳, 五行, 灾异

Abstract: Many scholars believe that Dong Zhongshu has both Yin and Yang thoughts and Five Elements thoughts,and believe that Dong Zhongshu uses the Five Elements to infer Yin and Yang and explain disasters.The complete statement of Dong Zhongshus “beginning to infer Yin and Yang” in “Hanshu:Five Elements” is “inferring Yin and Yang to explain disasters and anomalies”,which means using the theory of Yin and Yang to explain the occurrence of disasters and anomalies,rather than using Five Elements to infer Yin and Yang.According to Dong Zhongshus documents that have not been falsified,in Dong Zhongshus thoughts,Yin and Yang are the theoretical basis for his discussion of punishments and virtues,monarchs and ministers,the four seasons,and disasters;while the words “Five Elements” are mentioned accidentally due to the influence of popular concepts,and this cannot be considered that he has Five Elements thoughts.Of course,Dong Zhongshu did not combine Yin and Yang with the Five Elements.Although Dong Zhongshus writings on disasters and anomalies are mainly collected in “Hanshu:Five Elements”,Dong Zhongshus theory of explaining disasters and anomalies is not the Five Elements,but the “original providence” and the “inference of Yin and Yang”.

Key words: Dong Zhongshu, Yin and Yang, Five Elements, disasters and anomalies

中图分类号: