河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2018, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (2): 62-67.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-6378.2018.02.009

• 哲学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

戴维森基于真与意义的无指称的实在论

穆青   

  1. 河北大学 政法学院, 河北 保定 071002
  • 收稿日期:2017-08-03 出版日期:2018-03-25 发布日期:2018-03-25
  • 作者简介:穆青(1987—),男,河北沧州人,河北大学政法学院博士研究生,主要研究方向:逻辑哲学。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金项目“达米特与戴维森意义理论及其对当代逻辑学和哲学的影响之比较研究”(14BZX073);河北省研究生创新资助项目“戴维森意义理论的运行机制与自然语言语义学纲领研究”(S2016014)

Davidson’s Non-referential Realism Based on Truth and Meaning

MU Qing   

  1. College of Political Science and Law, Hebei University, Baoding, Hebei 071002, China
  • Received:2017-08-03 Online:2018-03-25 Published:2018-03-25

摘要: 戴维森认为,传统的意义理论和真理理论以指称概念作为理论基础,存在着难以对其进行深入分析的理论缺陷。整体论的方法也存在建构意义理论和真理理论的困难。为了解决这些困难,使意义理论和真理理论得到更加清晰的阐释,戴维森对这些问题进行了权衡比较。最终,他将绝对真理视为先于指称、满足等概念的前分析概念,对指称、满足这样的语义学概念进行严格限制,形成了可行的整体论真理理论和意义理论。此时指称概念与满足概念只是绝对真理理论当中的一种理论设定,只具有语义学的作用,并不具有对绝对真理整体的解释作用。同时,绝对真理理论同意义理论之间的关系,也在上述问题的澄清过程中得到阐释。戴维森将这种形式的绝对真理理论自身称作一种意义理论。绝对真理概念的建立在戴维森意义理论当中发挥着对于语言意义的绝对建构作用。戴维森的语言哲学体系当中,绝对真理概念是唯一的核心和唯一的前分析概念。这决定了他坚定的实在论立场。

关键词: 意义理论, 绝对真理, 指称

Abstract: Davidson believes that the traditional theory of meaning and the theory of truth take the concept of reference as the theoretical basis, and there are some theoretical defects which are difficult to be deeply analyzed. At the same time, the holistic approach, also has difficulties in constructing the meaning theory and the truth theory. In order to solve these difficulties and make the theory of meaning and the theory of truth be more clearly explained, Davidson weighed and compared these points of view. Finally, he regards absolute truth as the basis of the pre-analysis concept of reference, satisfaction and other concepts. He strictly limits the semantics of reference and satisfaction, and forms a feasible holism theory of truth and meaning. At this point, the reference concept and the concept of satisfaction are only a theoretical setting in the theory of absolute truth, and have only the function of semantics, and they do not have the explanatory function of the whole of absolute truth. At the same time, the relation between the theory of absolute truth and the theory of meaning is also explained in the clarification of the above problems. Davidson calls this theory of absolute truth itself a theory of meaning. The establishment of the concept of absolute truth plays an absolute role in the construction of linguistic meaning in Davidson’s meaning theory. In Davidson’s philosophy of language, the concept of absolute truth is the only core and the only pre analytic concept. This determined his firm stand of realism.

Key words: theory of meaning, absolute truth, reference

中图分类号: