公共价值管理理论的研究进展与前瞻

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1005-6378.2017.06.017

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 公共价值管理理论作为西方公共治理前沿理论之一,在20多年的发展历程中,受到国内外公共管理学者的广泛关注。国外学者以马克·穆尔、巴里·波兹曼、格里·斯托克为代表,形成了马克·穆尔为代表的创造公共价值、波兹曼为代表的公共价值失灵、斯托克为代表的作为网络化治理新途径的公共价值管理等观点。国外期刊也设专刊讨论公共价值,推进了公共价值管理理论的发展。国内学者从公共价值理论诠释与解析、政府战略管理、公共行政范式转换、网络化治理等角度来理解公共价值管理理论,多角度的讨论使其概念更加清晰,同时在绩效管理和政府职能创新方面的应用研究也有不少学者在探讨。通过公共价值管理理论研究现状的梳理与分析,展望我国公共价值管理理论的趋势。

关键词: 公共价值, 创造公共价值, 公共价值管理

Abstract: As one of the leading theories of western public governance, public value management theory has been widely concerned by scholars at home and abroad for more than 20 years. Mark Moore, Barry Boltzmann, and Gerry Stock are the representatives of foreign scholars, and Mark Moore is regarded as the representative of the creation of public value, Bozeman as the failure of public value, and Stock as the representative of the new approach to network governance of public value management. Foreign journals also set special discussion of public value, and promote the development of public value management theory. Domestic scholars understand the theory of public value management from the perspective of interpretation and analysis of public value theory, the perspective of government strategic management, the transformation of public administration paradigm, and network governance. Multi angle discussions make the concept clearer. In the performance management and the innovation of government functions, there are many scholars in the study. Through the research of the current situation of public value management theory, the author found the prospect of public value management research in China.

Key words: public value, creating public value, public value management

中图分类号:

D630

韩兆柱,郭红霞. 公共价值管理理论的研究进展与前瞻[J]. 河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2017, 42(6): 118-127.

HAN Zhao-zhu, GUO Hong-xia. The Research Progress and Prospects of Public Value Management Theory[J]. JOURNAL OF HEBEI UNIVERSITY (Philosophy and Social Science), 2017, 42(6): 118-127.

参考文献

[1] JOHN M BRYSON.Creating Public Value in a Multi-Sector,Shared-Power World, PAR Special Issue 2014[J].Public Administration Review,2012,72(1):166—167.
[2] IESTYN WILLIAMS,HEATHER SHEARER.Appraising Public Value: Past Present and Futures [J].Public Administration,2011,89(4):1367-1384.
[3] 孙珠峰,胡伟.公共行政的发展趋势:西方的预测与中国的逻辑[J].上海交通大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2014,22(6):74-83.
[4] MARK H MOORE.Creating Public Value:Strategic Management In Government [M]. Cambridge, Massachusetts:Harvard University Press,1995:30-52.
[5] KELLY,MUERS,MULGAN. Creating Public Value:An Analytical Framework for Public Service Reform[M]. London:Cabinet Office,UK Government,2002:4.
[6] HORNER,HAZEL.Adding Public Value[M].London:The Work Foundation,2005:34.
[7] GERRY STOKER.Public Value Management:A New Narrative for Networked Governance?[J].American Review of Public Administration,2006,36(1):41-57.
[8] O’FLYNN.From From New Public Management to Public Value:Paradigmatic Change and Managerial Implications[J].Public Administration Review,2007,66(3):353-366.
[9] JφRGENSEN,BOZEMAN.Public Values:An Inventory[J].Administration&Society, 2007, 39(3): 354-381.
[10] TIMO MEYNHARDT.Public Value Inside: What is Public Value Creation?[J].International Journal of Public Administration,2009,32(3-4):192-219.
[11] JOHN BENINGTON.Creating the Public In Order To Create Public Value?[J].International Journal of Public Administration,2009,32(3-4):232-249.
[12] COLIN TALBOT. Public Value—The Next“Big Thing”in Public Management?[J].International Journal of Public Administration,200932(3-4):167-170.
[13] MARK H MOORE.Public Value As the Focus of Strategy [J]. Australian Journal of Public Administration.1994,53(3):296-303.
[14] MARK H MOORE.Creating Public Value:Strategic Management In Government [M].Cambridge, Massachusetts:Harvard University Press,1995:28.
[15] BARRY BOZEMAN.Public Value Failure:When Efficient Markets May Not Do[J].Public Administration Review,2002,62(2):145-161.
[16] JφRGENSEN,BOZEMAN.Public Values:An Inventory[J].Administration&Society,2007,39(3):354-381.
[17] THOMAS FISHER.Public Value and the Integrative Mind: How Multiple Sectors Can Collaborate in City Building[J].Public Administration Review,2014,74(4):457–464.
[18] GERRY STOKER.Public Value Management:A New Narrative for Networked Governance?[J].American Review of Public Administration,2006,36(1):41-57.
[19] GERRY STOKER. Public Value Management(PVM):A New Resolution of Democracy/Efficiency Trade-off[Z]. Institution for Political and Economic Governance University of Manchester UK,2005.
[20] GERRY STOKER.Public Value Management:A New Narrative for Networked Governance?[J].American Review of Public Administration,2006,36(1):41-57.
[21] JOHN M BRYSON,BARBARA C CROSBY,LAURA BLOOMBERG.Public Value Governance:Moving Beyond Traditional Public Administration and the New Public Management[J].Public Administration Review,2014,74(4):445-456.
[22] KELLY G, MUERS S.Creating public value: An analytical framework for public service reform[M]. Discussion paper prepared by the Cabinet Office Strategy Unit Kingdom.2002.
[23] GERRY STOKER.Public Value Management:A New Narrative for Networked Governance? [J].American Review of Public Administration,2006,36(1):41-57.
[24] O’FLYNN.From From New Public Management to Public Value:Paradigmatic Change and Managerial Implications[J].The Australian Journal of Public Administration Review,2007,66(3):353-366.
[25] ADAM DAHL JOE SOSS. Neoliberalim for the Common Good? Public Value Govermence and the Downsizing of Democracy[J].Public Administration Review,2014,74(4):496-504.
[26] BERTHA LEWIS.Th e Paralysis of Analysis[J].Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):517-518.
[27] 约翰·克莱顿·托马斯:公共政策中的公民参与[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2012:8.
[28] 杨博,谢光远.论“公共价值管理”:一种后新公共管理理论的超越与限度[J].政治学研究,2014,(06):110-122.
[29] ESTYN WILLIAMS, HEATHER SHEARER. Appraising Public Value: Past,Present,and Futures[J]. Public Administration, 2011,89(4):1367-1385.
[30] LAURA KALAMBOKIDIS.Creating Public Value with Tax and Spending Policies: The View from Public Economics[J].Public Administration Review,2014,74(4):519-526.
[31] ABRAHAM LACKMAN.Is the Public Economics Toolbox Applicable to Budget Analysis?[J].Public Administration Review,2014,74(4):527-528.
[32] LAWRENCE R JACOBS.The Contested Politics of Public Value[J].Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):480-494.
[33] HANK SHEINKOPF. Value-Driven Public Policy Likely Requires Value-Driven Public Servants[J].Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):494–495.
[34] MARK H MOORE.Public Value Accounting: Establishing the Philosophical Basis[J].Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):465–477.
[35] RICHARD L BRODSKY.“Public Value”and the Measurement of Government Performance: The Shift to Subjective[J]. Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):478-479.
[36] 蓝志勇,陈国权.当代西方公共管理前沿理论述评[J].公共管理学报,2007(3):1-13.
[37] 蓝志勇.公共利益意识是建设和谐社会的文化核心[J].中国行政管理,2006(6):21-22.
[38] 尹文嘉.公共价值管理:西方公共管理发展的新动向[J].天府新论,2009(6):91-95.
[39] 王学军,张弘.公共价值的研究路径与前沿问题[J].公共管理学学报,2013(2):126-144.
[40] 孙珠峰,胡伟.后新公共管理时代钟摆现象[J].南京社会科学,2013(9):68-75.
[41] 马婷婷,唐兴霖.公共价值管理:西方公共行政学理论的新发展[J].行政论坛,2014(6):100-106.
[42] 韩兆柱,翟文康.西方公共治理理论体系的构建及对我国的启示[J].河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2016(6):96-104.
[43] 陈振明.战略管理的实施与公共价值的创造——评穆尔《创造公共价值:政府中的战略管理》[J] 东南学术,2006(2):27-34.
[44] 赵景华,李代民.政府战略管理三角模型评析与创新[J].中国行政管理,2009(6):47-49.
[45] 赵景华,李宇环.公共战略管理的价值取向与分析模型[J].中国行政管理,2011(12):32-37.
[46] 包国宪,保海旭.以公共价值为基础的政府战略管理[J].兰州大学学报,2015(4)24-30.
[47] 何艳玲.“公共价值管理”:一种新的公共行政学范式[J].政治学研究,2009(5):62.
[48] 马晓霞.中国公共行政范式的全新阐释——从价值理论和制度层面构建行政范式[J].鸡西大学学报,2009(1):30-32.
[49] 娄成武,谭羚雁.西方公共治理理论研究综述[J].甘肃理论学刊,2012(2):114-119.
[50] 董礼胜,王少泉.工具——价值理性分野下西方行政理论学变迁[J].中国行政管理,2014(1):114-118.
[51] 斯蒂芬·戈德斯密斯,威廉·D埃格斯:网络化治理:公共部门的新形态[M].孙迎春,译.北京:北京大学出版社,2008:6.
[52] 尹文嘉.公共价值管理:西方公共管理理论发展的新动向[J].领导与科学,2009(10):17-19.
[53] 董礼胜,李玉耘.工具—价值理性分野下西方公共行政理论的变迁[J].政治学研究,2010(1):65-71.
[54] 李俊生,王斌.试论公共价值革命—关于公共管理范式对21世纪财政理论发展影响的若干思考[J].中央财经大大学学报,2010(6):1-6.
[55] 包国宪,文宏,王学军.基于公共价值的政府绩效管理学科体系构建[J].中国行政管理,2012(5):98-104.
[56] BAO G,WANG X G,et al.Beyond New Public Governance:A Value-Based Global Framework for Performance Management,Governance and Leadership[J].Administration and Society,2013(4):443-467.
[57] 包国宪,王学军.以公共价值为基础的政府绩效治理——源起、架构与研究问题[J].公共管理学报,2012(2):89-127.
[58] 樊胜岳.基于公共价值的生态建设政策绩效评价研究[J].行政论坛,2013(4):34-39.
[59] 聂莹.生态建设项目的公共价值分析与绩效评价体系构建[J].河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2016(2):135-140.
[60] 卢梅花,卓越.基于公共价值计分卡的的政府绩效审计通用指标框架[J].行政论坛,2013(6):14-19.
[61] 董丽.基于公共价值的电子政府服务质量测评研究[J].电子政务,2012(11):30-36.
[62] 王学军,张弘.公共价值的研究路径与前沿问题[J].公共管理学学报,2013(2):126-144.
[63] 吴春梅,翟军亮.公共价值管理理论中的政府职能创新启示[J].行政论坛,2014(1):13-17.
[64] 赵强,单炜.大数据政府创新:基于大数据流的公共价值创造[J].中国社会科学论坛,2014(12):23-27.
[65] 韩兆柱,翟文康.公共价值管理理论在中国语境下的应用研究[J].公共管理与政策评论,2016(4):22-29.
[66] 丹尼尔·A·雷恩(Daniel A. Wren),阿瑟·G·贝德安(Arthur G. Bedeian).管理思想史[M].孙健敏,黄小勇,李原,译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2015:583.
[67] 王学军,张弘.公共价值的研究路径与前沿问题[J].公共管理学报,2013(2):126-144.