关键词: 党内法规, 党外效力, 正当性, 证成范式, 学说史

Abstract: The development of the paradigm of the force about Party regulations in the academic circles has gone through the turn of the quadruple paradigm of the theory of indirect influence,the theory of constitutional logic,the theory of social systems, and the relationship between the Party and the government. No matter what approach is taken,it cant meet the needs of proof on the supply side of theory,or it is out of touch with the practice of Party regulations,or there are logical contradictions,or it is debatable in terms of proof,persuasiveness and scientific methodology.This paper summarizes and reflects on the advantages and disadvantages of different approaches,and argues that only from the local logic and self-orientation of the growth of Party regulations can a set of theoretical logic that meets the needs of the force of Party regulations outside the Party be constructed.

Key words: Party regulations, extra force, legitimacy, proof paradigm, the history of doctrine