河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (4): 13-18.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-6378.2019.04.003

• 文学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

宋词“入代(替)平声”说之检讨

田玉琪,李雪铭   

  1. 河北大学 文学院, 河北 保定 071002
  • 收稿日期:2018-05-20 出版日期:2019-07-25 发布日期:2019-07-25
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金一般项目“唐宋词声律史研究”(13BZW070)

Review on “Checked Tone Replacing Level Tone” in Ci in Song Dynasty

TIAN Yu-qin, LI Xue-ming   

  1. College of Literature, Hebei University, Baoding, Hebei 071002, China
  • Received:2018-05-20 Online:2019-07-25 Published:2019-07-25

摘要: 宋词创作中“入代(替)平声”说由宋末沈义父首倡,清代《词律》《词谱》诸书在词谱编撰中普遍运用了这一观点并加以引申发挥,而戈载的《词林正韵》更从词曲一理的角度将入代平声说进行了理论归纳并对入代平声之字作了具体罗列。宋词创作中确有入代平声的现象,但是总的来看,入代平声还是词人偶然的运用,不是必然的法则,入声与平声之间的界限还是非常分明。《词林正韵》即分入声五部,又将入声派入三声之中,颇为自相矛盾,而其所列入作平声之字,并不符合宋人创作的实际情况,更多的是戈载自己根据曲韵之书的编造,淆乱词曲用字之界,不足为凭。至于哪些入声字可以偶代平声而用,还是要对今存宋人作品的入声字详加考察之后才能得出结论;而今日词体之创作,亦不宜“入代平声”。

关键词: 唐宋词, 入代平声, 《词律》, 《词谱》, 《词林正韵》

Abstract: The rule of “checked tone replacing level tone” in Ci in Song Dynasty was initiated by Shen Yifu and was extensively applied and expounded in compilation of numerous Ci works in such books as Rules of Ci and A Collection of Tunes in Ci. Further, Ci and Tunes by Ge Zai presents summarized theories on checked tone replacing level tone from the angle of the same origin of Ci and lyrics and also lists some examples of checked tone replacing level tone. In spite of the presence of checked tone replacing level tone in Ci in Song Dynasty, checked tone replacing level tone only sees occasional applications by Ci poets and does not necessarily represent a law. A clear boundary still remains between the checked tone and level tone. In Ci and Tunes, the checked tone falls into four parts and is also included in the range of falling-rising tone, thus which is rather paradoxical. Further, characters incorporated in level tone do not meet the actual conditions in creation of Ci of Song Dynasty. More applications in it were compiled by Ge Zai himself based on rhyming books, and confused the boundary of characters used in poems and lyrics, presenting no enough evidence. Conclusions cant be drawn before detailed investigation on characters of checked tones in existing Song works as to which characters can replace those of level tone.

Key words: Ci in Tang and Song Dynasties, checked tone replacing level tone

中图分类号: