河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版) ›› 2023, Vol. 48 ›› Issue (2): 44-51.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-6378.2023.02.009

• 哲学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

戴维森、达米特的实在论、反实在论之争的形而上学渊源

穆青   

  1. 沧州师范学院 政史学院, 河北 沧州 061000
  • 收稿日期:2022-04-13 出版日期:2023-03-25 发布日期:2023-03-25
  • 作者简介:穆青(1987—),男,河北沧州人,博士,沧州师范学院副教授,主要研究方向:逻辑哲学、语言哲学、当代形而上学。
  • 基金资助:
    河北省高等学校人文社会科学研究青年拔尖人才计划项目“戴维森、普特南实在论思想比较研究”(BJ2019218);国家社会科学基金项目“达米特与戴维森意义理论及其对当代逻辑学和哲学的影响之比较研究”(14BZX073)

The Metaphysical Origin of the Debate between Davidson and Dummetts Realism and Anti-realism

MU Qing   

  1. School of Political History, Cangzhou Normal University, Cangzhou, Hebei 061000, China
  • Received:2022-04-13 Online:2023-03-25 Published:2023-03-25

摘要: 西方形而上学整体演进的理论视域下,实在一词具有核心性价值。当代实在论、反实在论思想的特定形态,是由哲学传统中不同形态的本体论,经过认识论的过渡,最终转向语言从而生成的。这为西方形而上学发展脉络的明晰提供了关键支撑。代表不同哲学发展阶段具体形态的实在论思想,定会引发与之对应的反实在论。这种构成各个阶段的形而上学主题的方式,应被视为“实在—反实在”哲学范式。西方形而上学的整体发展在这一独特视角下呈现为二者具体理论形态之演进。戴维森、达米特的实在论、反实在论之争是以此为理论渊源,基于现代逻辑、当代意义理论的新进展所形成的西方哲学后语言转向的新产物。继弗雷格、维特根斯坦之后,戴维森、达米特开启的基于意义与真的实在问题之争,决定了各类不同程度、形态的实在论观点所坚守的共同理论底线。这一理论临界点和论争焦点就是是否坚持二值原则。

关键词: 实在论, 反实在论, 形而上学, 二值原则

Abstract: From the theoretical perspective of the overall evolution of western metaphysics,the word “reality” has a core value.The specific forms of contemporary realism and anti-realism are generated by the different forms of ontology in the philosophical tradition,through the transition of epistemology,and finally turn to language.This provides key support for the clarity of the development of western metaphysics.Realism,which represents the specific forms of different philosophical development stages,will inevitably lead to corresponding anti-realism.This way of forming the metaphysical theme of each stage should be regarded as the philosophical paradigm of “reality—anti-reality”.Under this unique perspective,the overall development of western metaphysics presents the evolution of their specific theoretical forms.The debate between Davidson and Dummett on realism and anti-realism is a new product of the post-linguistic turn of western philosophy based on the theoretical origin and the new development of modern logic and contemporary meaning theory.After Frege and Wittgenstein,Davidson and Dummett started the debate on the issue of reality based on meaning and truth,which determined the common theoretical bottom line adhered to all kinds of realism views of different degrees and forms.The critical point of this theory and the focus of controversy is whether to adhere to the two-value principle.

Key words: realism, anti realism, metaphysics, two-value principle

中图分类号: